We can see the artists ranked from the darkest (with the winner being Jimmy Giuffre for his extract from Pickin'em up and layin'em down) to the most brilliant (a title awarded to Giora Feidman for his extract from The Klezmer's Freilach). The mean result of the ratings assigned to each extract for these two descriptors is shown in the following graphs: Half of the participants are both clarinetists and saxophonists. This panel of participants included 80% saxophonists and 72% clarinetists. No less than 300 participants answered this questionnaire and rated the different extracts in terms of power and brightness. The questionnaire is still available here. They were asked to rate each extract according to two scales: Brightness and Power. They were presented through an online survey and their identity was concealed from the participants. In order to illustrate the different levels for the chosen scales, we carried out a second experiment: we selected 11 extracts between 5 and 10 seconds long from recordings of well-known 20th century clarinetists. These two descriptors are already used to describe the saxophone sound and we are going to keep them to describe the clarinet sound. ![]() Power descriptor: ranging from soft to powerful, with each term being used by more than 40% of the musicians in our panel.Brightness descriptor: ranging from dark to bright, with each term being used by 30% of the musicians in our panel.At the top of the list are, among other things, the following: Some 40 clarinetists came to try out mouthpieces in our studio and formulated a total of over 900 adjectives in French and English!Īfter processing the results, a list of about 15 commonly used adjectives emerges. ![]() This is a method called free verbalization. The participant tries out mouthpieces with different geometries he is invited to comment on his impressions, and therefore issue descriptors. To find this "lingua franca", the Syos studio recently hosted an abundance of musicians to took part in various tests: In practice, how did this common vocabulary come about?
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |